top of page
man with a phone head set doing customer service calls

PAYMENTS
& CLAIMS

PAYMENT AND INSURANCE CLAIM INFORMATION

Making Payments and Insurance Claims

at Mitchell-Joseph Insurance

At Mitchell-Joseph Insurance, an independent insurance agency representing 24 individual insurance carriers, we want to make the process of making payments or filing claims as efficient as possible. Therefore, below you will find contact information for all of our insurance carriers and suggest that you contact them directly with payment information or to file a claim. In the past, when our clients called Mitchell-Joseph Insurance to make a payment or file a claim, we would take down all of their information, call their insurance company who ultimately would call our clients to confirm the information was correct. We thought this was a waste of our clients' valuable time since they would need to repeat everything. Now, we ask that you make direct contact with your insurance company so that the entire process flows more smoothly and efficiently. Just be sure to have your policy number ready. Please call us if you have any questions about this payments and claims process. 

Contact Information for Our Insurance Companies

Allstate insurance logo

Claims: (800) 386-6126
Claims Fax: (866) 447-4293
Billing: (800) 336-9400
Auto Glass: (800) 626-4527
Credit Card: (800) 255-7828​​

erie and niagara insurance

Main Phone: (800) 234-9876
Claims Fax: (716) 632-9621​​

Farm & Country Insurance Logo

Claims: (800) 258-2494

585-624-2474
Claims Fax: 585-624-2268​​

foremost insurance logo

Claims/Billing: (800) 527-3905​​

hagerty insurance logo

Claims: (800) 385-0274
Billing: (800) 747-5348

Fax: (231) 941-8227​​

main street insurance logo

Claims: (877) 425-2467
Claims Fax: (877) 282-3844
Billing: (877) 927-5672
Auto Glass: (800) 887-5944

ontario insurance logo

Claims/Billing: (800) 232-2799
Claims Fax: (866) 481-9115

progressive insurance logo

Claims: (800) 274-4499
Billing: (800) 925-2886
Credit Card: (800) 888-7764
Roadside: (800) 776-2778
Tow Claims Fx: (800) 876-6078

sterling insurance logo

Claims: (800) 462-4661
Claims Fax: (518) 234-8570
Billing: (800) 462-4661
Auto Glass: (800) 790-9997

travelers insurance logo

Claims/Billing: (800) 842-8574
Auto Glass: (866) 878-4527

Flood Claims: (800) 356-6670

utica national insurance logo

Claims: (800) 216-1420
Claims Fax: (888) 538-2018
Billing: (800) 598-8422
Auto Glass: (800) 216-1420
Tow Claims Fx: (315) 734-2976

bottom of page